SciFi Scanner

Science Fiction Movies, News and Discussion

Mary Robinette Kowal - Nine Candidates for the Next Where the Wild Things Are

WTWTA_Books_560x330.jpgMary_Robinette_Kowal.jpg

When I first heard Spike Jonze was adapting Maurice Sendak's Where the Wild Things Are as a feature, my reaction was along the lines of Buh-Wha? I mean, the story has nine sentences. Nine. You see, in order to make a successful transition to screen, a picture book has to have sufficient conflict to withstand expansion while still maintaining a sense of wonder. By most reports, Wild Things actually pulled it off. So in honor of its nine-sentence leap, here are nine picture books I would like to see following in its footsteps, er, paw-steps.

1. Corduroy by Don Freeman
It's perfect! A small toy bear gets lost in a big department store searching desperately for a lost button. Lisa, the girl who brings him home, is wonderful too, scraping together the money to buy him all by herself. The 1984 TV adaptation was a paltry 16 minutes. Give me a feature that expands on our two heroes' efforts any day. Think Spike Jonze could be talked into it?

2. Harold and the Purple Crayon by Crockett Johnson
Grant me the power of that purple crayon so I can create the world! Whatever Harold draws with his crayon comes to life. This too had an animated TV adaptation, but give the property to Henry Selick and Laika Studios (of Coraline fame) and let the wonder really begin. See, this would be a great story for Selick's stylized stop motion as Harold's drawings go from 2D to 3D. A veritable visual feast, I say.

3. If You Give a Mouse A Cookie by Laura Numeroff
Stuart Little's shenanigans are nothing compared to the conniving things the Mouse here pulls off. He starts by asking the boy for a cookie, and from there his entitled demands escalate exponentially. It's classic, I tell you. It could work well as a combination live action and puppet tale that deals with the consequences of greed. Hand it over to Frank Oz, and enjoy the slapstick.

4. Wolves in the Walls by Neil Gaiman
Come on, we already know that Neil Gaiman translates beautifully to the big screen with the success of Stardust and Coraline. Bring in Dave McKeen, the illustrator, who also directed the visually fantastic MirrorMask and you'd have a stunning picture. It's worked on stage, so what's a little jump to the screen? It'll be scary -- there are, after all, wolves living in the walls of Lucy's house from whom she has to rescue her family -- but it's a tale of resourcefulness and bravery in the face of the unknown.

5. Olivia by Ian Falconer
With Olivia, expanding the circus pig's adventures into a feature length movie is a piece of cake because there are several books to choose from. Plus, it's already worked as a TV series. Call me crazy, but I'd love to see what Gus Van Sant would do with the minimalist setting of the books. It could be a beautiful juxtaposition, compelling to children and adults alike.

6. Ferdinand by Munro Leaf
This was one of my favorites as a kid, and I honestly have no idea how it could be adapted into a feature -- which might explain why Disney only tackled it as a short in 1938. But if you did a combination of live action and CGI à la Babe, you could have a heartwarming story of a bull who would rather smell flowers than fight matadors. Heck, give the project to Babe's Chris Noonan and see what he can do with it.

7. The True Story of the Three Little Pigs by A. Wolf by John Scieszka
They say that history is always written by the victors, so who knows what actually happened between the pigs and the wolf. This hilarious story is loaded with conflict and creativity. In Tim Burton's hands, the twisted nature of the story about a wolf with a cold looking to borrow a cup of sugar from some nasty pigs could totally shine. Plus, Johnny Depp as A. Wolf? Perfection.

8. Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day by Judith Viorst
This is a total no-brainer because there's already a full-length stage version of the book -- and it's a musical! There's no shortage of conflict as Alexander goes through his very bad day -- from waking up late to getting splashed by the bus -- and in the hands of Ron Howard, this would be the feel good movie of the season.

9. Alpha-Oops by Alethea Kontis
The premise is simple: The letter Z is tired of going last, so during the alphabet pageant all the letters shuffle. As an animated adventure it could be a load of fun ranging from the inherent comedy of theater gone horribly wrong to real stories of friendship. "A movie about alphabet characters?" you say. If there can be a successful flick where the main characters are vegetables, really, I don't think letters will be a problem.

What picture books would you like to see leaping to the silver screen?

Mary Robinette Kowal is the winner of the 2008 John W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer and a professional puppeteer. Her first novel, Shades of Milk and Honey, is being published by Tor in 2010.

  • Comments (9)
  • (1)
  • Link
  • Add This!

Filed under: Mary Robinette Kowal
Tags: where the wild things are

Comments

user-pic

Strangely enough, Spike Jonze said he wanted to do "Harold and the Purple Crayon". And Disney WAS going to do "The True Story of the 3 Little Pigs", but it never got past development. :(

default userpic

I think "Click, Clack, Moo: Cows that Type" by Doreen Cronin and Betsy Lewin would make a good movie. It has humor that works on the level of children and adults. Thre is also the political tension between the Cows and Farmer Brown. There are several book in this series if the material runs thin.

Don't forget that the book "Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs" has a sequel, "Pickles to Pittsburgh." You've been warned.

If you want an interesting book with around nine words, look at "Tuesday" by David Wiesner. The book only lists times and the pictures tell the rest of the story. My guess is that only Stanley Kubrick could adapt that to a feature movie (and he would get three hours out of it.)

If you are wondering why I know too much about picture books, I am married to an elementary school teacher and have two kids under six.

default userpic

How about the 'Good Dog, Carl' series- I'm thinking that the Christmas one where he and the baby go Christmas shopping.

user-pic

I would have actually chosen The Day I Swapped My Dad for Two Goldfish over The Wolves in the Walls for a Neil Gaiman choice. But why choose? Let's just have them both.

I also think The Man Who Took the Indoors Out by Arnold Lobel would be FANTASTIC (the book itself only eludes to the antics the furniture gets into once it leaves the house) -- but good luck trying to find an actual copy of that book, never mind the film rights.

And...SQUEE! I am ridiculously honored to be on that list in SUCH good company.

user-pic

LaDracul: No kidding? Well, let's hope he gets the rights someday.

OmegaLimit: I LOVE Click, Clack, Moo and I have no excuses for liking picture books.

PamAdams: Oh, yeah. Those would be good.

Alethea: You know, I initially had The Day I Swapped My Dad for Two Goldfish as one of my choices, but figured Wolves would have better action sequences. Plus I want someone to hire Stan Winston Studios to make the wolves. Creepy!

default userpic

Now I feel I need to explain myself. I am not putting down anybody for liking children's books.

As a 33 year-old guy with a beard, I worry that parents would get the wrong idea if I went to see "Up" by myself. When I wrote the "If you are wondering" part, I was just trying to say "Hey, I'm not a crazy stalker guy." I forgot that nobody can see me on the internet.

While we have Alethea's attention, I had a teacher, Mrs. Welsh, who took attendance in reverse alphabetical order to give the people at the end of the list a break.

default userpic

Unfortunately, Henry Selick and Laika have parted ways. Otherwise, great suggestions! As someone who's been reading aloud to various younger relatives and offspring of family friends since the 1970's, I've enjoyed most of these books myself.

I'd be interested to see a feature film version of the "Miss Nelson" books of Harry Allard and James Marshall. Though not fantasy, the recurring character Viola Swamp (the "meanest substitute teacher in the world" and "a real witch") embodies a certain fantasy archetype.

No suggestions as to who should direct, but I'd cast Nicole Kidman as the title character, a sweet-natured 2nd-grade teacher driven to distraction by her chronically misbehaving charges; one day without warning she goes missing and is replaced by Miss Swamp. Kidman does sweet-natured very well, plus she has a proven ability to act under heavy makeup (in The Hours), which should come in handy for the other half of her role....

Incidentally, there is a minor connection between Tim Burton and the other creator of The True Story of the Three Little Pigs by A. Wolf, illustrator Lane Smith--Smith did character designs for the Disney version of James and the Giant Peach, co-produced by Tim Burton (and directed by Henry Selick).

user-pic

Could I float the idea that some things don't need to be movies?

Some things are perfect as they are, and do not really need a new version or a new interpretation.

Make movies from movie ideas. Leave the books alone.

default userpic

This reminds me of Disney's Mulan. It was not based on a picture book, but rather, a poem. The first half of the poem describe how Mulan made the decision to join the army, and the second half describes how happy the family is when she came back. In the middle were 30 Chinese characters (that's 30 syllables) that describe everything that happened in between, which can be summarized as "They went. The battle was fierce. They came back." And somehow they managed to make a whole story out of that too.

Leave a comment