Mary Robinette Kowal - For Teens in Fantasy, It's Not Easy Being Big


I've been thinking a lot about the growing process lately, as we're getting ready for my fifteen-year old nephew to come visit. The task of finding things that will be fun for him to do in New York is an interesting one, because it requires me to actively remember what it was like to be a teenager. So, I thought that this week, we would take a look at the unique ways fantasy can shed light on the desires and conflicts of growing up.
One of the feelings I remember most as a teen was the belief that everything would be different -- people would listen to me -- if I were just a grown-up. In Big (1988) Josh Baskin (David Moscow & Tom Hanks) embodies that belief, and feels thwarted at every turn by his small stature.The thirteen-year-old makes a wish on a carnival fortune teller and the next morning wakes up a 35-year old man. Being an adult is by turns terrifying and glorious -- and although Josh finds success in his new life, he also realizes what he's missing. Feeling like a child trapped in a man's body is a lot of what being a teenager is about -- if only teens could glean Josh's wisdom when he decides to stay a kid.
Big is not the only movie to explore the idea of body and soul reversal. Freaky Friday (1977) takes the same idea of children becoming adults, and also adds the reverse. Annabelle Adams (Jodie Foster) can't believe how hard her life is and is convinced her mother (Barbara Harris) can't understand the pressures of being a teenager. Her mother thinks that Annabelle can't understand what it's like to to parent two children. In a fateful moment, they both say, "I wish I could switch places with her for just one day" and swap bodies. There are times when you might wistfully sigh, "Oh, to be young again," but if you were actually offered the opportunity, would you take it? Freaky Friday viscerally demonstrates that neither adulthood nor teen life are all they are cracked up to be -- but more importantly, it demonstrates there is a time for everything, and no time like the present.
Teenagers usually don't need a specific motivation to display angst, and nowhere is that better demonstrated than in Mirrormask (2005). Helena (Stephanie Leonidas) has the life most kids dream about -- her parents run a circus, for crying out loud. In a fit of anger, she shouts at her mother the oft-repeated line, "I wish you were dead." When her mother collapses during an act, Helena retreats into her drawings to cope with her depression and guilt, crossing over into a fantastic world. Every window she looks through in that world shows her the world she came from, where a girl who looks like her exhibits every anti-social behavior invented by teenagers. As many parents complain, she really does become a different person. Only when Helena learns to accept her real life and her circumstances is she able to return to it.
Of course, no conversation about growing up fantasy would be complete without Peter Pan (2003). Peter (Jeremy Sumpter) -- a boy who never grows up -- represents not just the desire to stay a child, but childrens' active distrust of adults. Adults demand responsibility and are forever wanting kids to put away childish things. At the same time, they try to protect children from things that are too "adult," leaving them with a gaping view of the unknown. Is it any wonder that Neverland seems so appealing? Not only does it fulfill both child fantasies (playing all the time) and adult (taking care of yourself), but adults like Captain Hook treat them as equals and are completely transparent.
Fantasy movies are particularly adept at pointing out the transition from childhood to adulthood. It can be a frightening time, when you are too old to be a child, too young to be considered an adult. So when my nephew comes to visit, I think I'll try to find a play (he likes theater) that might be a little too "old" for him. And if he selects another activity that might be a little too "young" for me, I'll go along without complaint and let him take me on a brief sidetrip back to my youth. Fantasy is an excellent reminder that there is value in both, and that being in transition is a rare opportunity.
Mary Robinette Kowal is the winner of the 2008 John W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer and a professional puppeteer. Her first novel Shades of Milk and Honey is being published by Tor in 2010.










One of the movies that I thought actually dealt with the reversal idea pretty well (even if it was flawed in other ways), was Hook. Given an adult motivation (the kidnapping of his children), he's forced to go back to an idealized childhood world, and eventually finds it unsatisfying.
I also thought that it was one of the areas where the Narnia movies were very lacking- 4 kids, all of a sudden being forced to act as adults, with little to no exploration about what that would actually mean. There aren't too many 7-14 year olds (I'm guessing at the ages), who would be capable of making very adult decisions, and it tends to gloss over the consequences of the decisions that they do make. Although I liked the movies, I did think that they were lacking in that aspect.
I think Big did a great job on this. I was 19 when it came out, so I was passed this stage, but watching it as an adult I can re-live those moments of youth. What kid didn't want to be bigger, older, and listened to. Of course, we all learn later that it's not all fun and games. Now as an adult I think it would be fun to go the other way.
There was a body switch movie with Fred Savage and Judge Reinhold that was pretty good, too. It was called Vice Versa. It was basically the same concept of Freaky Friday. It seems they bring out these types of movie every 15 years or so, just to capture a new generation of kids. And adults.
Star Trek had several good episodes on this topic. The best is "Miri," where an attempt to prolong life instead kills all the adults while making the children long-lived - until they reach puberty, when they all die. This leads to a "Lord of the Flies" type society. Miri is the central character here, as she is about 15-16 and the prototypical troubled teen.
Almost as good is "Charlie X," which has a troubled 17-year-old given super powers, and who ends up believing he's ready to be an adult and to handle his powers, but he's not quite ready for it.
In "And the Children Shall Lead," all the adults on a planet have been killed (that's twice they've done that - see a pattern here?), and the children run their own society, but are also not ready for this. (They are "helped" by an alien, that caused them to kill their parents.)
"The Squire of Gothos" is another, showing a childish alien being with super powers in the body of a man who plays with the Enterprise crew - until his parents show up.
And then there's "The Corbomite Maneuver," where the Enterprise seems to battle a super-powerful and ugly monster in a powerful ship, only to discover it's this small child-like being. (Who, by the way, was played by Ron Howard's little brother and star of the TV show "Gentle Ben," Clint Howard).
Addendum to previous note: I forgot that Mary only covers fantasy, and here I'm writing about Star Trek! Well, it's close.
It was amazing how many movies with similar themes came out right after the success of "Big". Some were kids wanting to be old and others were adults wanting to be kids.
The Corey Feldman movie "Dream a Little Dream" was probably the most popular. Wasn't there one with George Burns getting to be a teenager one more time? "18 Again" if I remember right.
I see the Zac Efron movie is going to go George one better with "17 Again" this spring.
I thought "13 Going on 30" with Jennifer Garner did a good job of updating it.
Stop putting ads for shows on the screen during movies, it is VERY annoying and only makes me NOT watch the show advertised! If you don't stop soon, I will stop watching your channel all together!