SciFi Scanner

Science Fiction Movies, News and Discussion

Mary Robinette Kowal - The Evolution of Women in Fantasy Movies

Ladyhawke_560x330_MSDLADY_EC009_H.jpgMary_Robinette_Kowal.jpg

Like with anything else, if you watch enough fantasy movies over a long enough period of time, you'll start to notice certain trends emerging. Today we're going to take a look at one of those trends: The evolution of women in fantasy from game pieces to players -- or to use a chess metaphor, from pawns to queens. Since we'll be looking at one of the most traditional female archetypes in all of fantasy -- the romantic lead -- I am deliberately restricting the movies we discuss to more traditional fantasy, or as they say in the biz, "high fantasy."

We'll begin by looking at 1963's Jason and the Argonauts. This classic bit of Greek mythology pits Jason (Todd Armstrong) as a game piece of the gods who travels with his manly band of Argonauts facing challenges. One such trial finds Jason and the Argonauts captured by King Aeëtes -- that is, until the king's daughter, Medea (Nancy Kovack), saves them. She's fallen hopelessly in love with the noble youth, for no apparent reason other than his manly chin. She betrays her father and her country for him, and aside from that she has no role in the movie. Can we blame it completely on the source material? Sadly, no. The original had a much more active role for Medea, along with a fairly believable character arc. Heck, she's one of the most powerful female figures in Greek mythology.

The next milestone happened in 1973's The Golden Voyage of Sinbad . The movie opens with Sinbad (John Phillip Law) finding a magical tablet, which he decides to sling around his neck as an amulet (why not?). That night he dreams of a beautiful woman with an eye tattooed on her palm. He follows the vision until he finds Margiana (Caroline Munro), a beautiful slave girl. Right... slave girl. And her role in the rest of the movie is? To be very pretty; to scream; to be rescued. Even though we don't have gods playing with the mortals, we still have game pieces.

Moving forwards another decade, we've got 1983's Ladyhawke. Here, the hero Navarre (Rutger Hauer) and his true love Isabeau (Michelle Pfeiffer) are victims of a curse that makes her a hawk by day and him a wolf by night, able to be together only for brief moments at sunrise and sunset. Both characters have a clear emotional arc and are carrying the same burden, but aside from one moment when Isabeau saves his life, the driver of the plot is Navarre. At the end of the movie, as Navarre goes to confront the Bishop who placed the curse on them, he leaves Isabeau with their confidant and tells him to kill her if he doesn't return. Wha? Kill her? The lady, it seems, would be too heartbroken to live without the man. Surely there are other options. Still, this flick has the hero and the heroine sharing more of the story than any adventure fantasy of the previous two decades.

The nineties featured a host fantasy movies with strong female characters, none more classic than Beauty and the Beast. What's interesting about Belle in this movie is her relationship with the three different men in her life -- her father, Gaston, and the Beast. Gaston is easily the best catch in the village, but Belle rebuffs his advances. Her father is more like a child than an authority figure, and she tends to him with motherly affection. Even with Beast she maintains a cold and calculated distance, not allowing him the satisfaction of making her comfortable in his palace. She's the one in charge, driving events throughout the story. No passive heroine here.

And that brings us to the 21st century. How do women fare these days? Let's use 2007's Stardust as our example. Tristan Thorn (Charlie Cox) is in love with the prettiest girl in the village, who plays him like a second-hand fiddle. So when she sees a meteor fall and sets it as the condition for marrying him, Tristan agrees without even thinking. When he finds the fallen star, it's actually an immortal woman named Yvaine (Claire Danes). He claims her as a trophy, but she's having none of it. They travel back to Tristan's village, predictably falling in love. What we see in this movie is a complete reversal of gender roles. It's Tristan who's at the mercy of other women, be they witches, townies, or fallen stars. Sure he gets the girl, but in this case it might be more appropriate to say the girl gets him.

What are your thoughts on heroines in traditional fantasy? Have they finally found equality?

Mary Robinette Kowal is the winner of the 2008 John W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer. She is also the art director at Shimmer Magazine and a professional puppeteer. Her column appears every Friday.

  • Comments (11)
  • (3)
  • Link
  • Add This!

Filed under: Mary Robinette Kowal
Tags: beauty and the beast, jason and the argonauts, ladyhawke, stardust, the golden voyage of sinbad

Comments

default userpic

I love how Stardust flips the usual "damsel in distress" role on its head. It's an underrated film, and an excellent novel (both in illustrated and non-illustrated form) that everyone should check out.

Obviously, the Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings films have given us some strong fantasy heroines. Galadriel is particularly complex and interesting.

I am also fond of Legend's Oona and Princess Lily, Willow's Sorsha, and, of course, Labyrinth's Sara.

user-pic

Those are all some good ones. Although, some of them, like Oona, aren't romantic female leads. There are loooooads of strong women in other roles...if you want to start counting all the witches, evil step-mothers, and wise old women.

default userpic

It seems that women in Fantasy are shown as stronger. Maybe not as strong as a 'Ripley' or 'Sarah Connor' from a Sci Fi movie, but they are moving away from the damsel in distress idea. Of course, I could be completely wrong.

user-pic

In general, I think you're right that they are moving away from Damsel's.

default userpic

I think as strong and smart women became more desirable in American society (reflecting the mainstreaming of the feminst movement), fantasy started to reflect those views. That's why Arwen played a more active role against the Nazgul in the movie than in the book. Pop culture reflects the values and concerns of the times that it's created in and for.

user-pic

Oh, excellent point about Arwen's role. I'd forgotten that they'd increased her level of activity there.

user-pic

Mulan is one of my all-time favorite films. While I'm not entirely certain it counts as fantasy (maybe slightly exaggerated historical fiction?), it certainly has a strong female protagonist!

Also from LotR: Éowyn has always been my favorite female character from the books, and I was happy with Miranda Otto's portrayal of Éowyn as well... another strong female character!

default userpic

As much as I love her, Buttercup was a step back in fantasy for women. She's not too bright, and has a tendency towards "Help me, Wesley!" rather than picking up a stick to beat anyone or thing that might be trying to kill him at the time. I think, though, that William Goldman, in the intervening time between book and movie, makes her a tad bit smarter and more active.

The fact that it's as SHE wishes from the get-go does show she's the one holding his cajones, though, doesn't it? Hmmmm.

user-pic

I have heard people say that, although a man may be the "head" of a household, the woman is the "neck" that controls it and holds it up. Some of the women in movies (Buttercup might be a good example... it's been a while since I've seen Princess Bride) who aren't strong physically and might seem to be "pawns" in the hands of the male protagonist have been the true driving force behind his motives and actions. Can't think of any good examples right now though...

user-pic

The "neck" of the household is an interesting saying and not one that I've heard before. I would argue that just because a woman is the driving force behind a man's motives and actions does not mean that she is anymore active than an Olympic gold metal. There must be intent. Buttercup is willful, but not very bright and clearly spoiled, expecting other people to solve things for her.

default userpic

One of my favorite 'kick-a**' heroines is Drew Barrymore in Ever After. She may be Cinderella- but she's the one saving Prince Charming. I loved the scene where she saves him from the gypsies.

Leave a comment