How Future Batman Installments Can Live Up to The Dark Knight

Nick Nadel's Tuesday column examines the increasingly busy intersection between comic books and the movies.
So, it's safe to say that The Dark Knight will pretty much be the greatest comic book movie ever made. No less an authority on the subject than Kevin Smith (Clerks, Dogma) has already called it the "Godfather II of comic book films." But what's next? Sadly, the planned two-film Joker storyline will never come to fruition. While Harvey Dent/Two-Face seems to be a definite possibility for the next outing, fans are already buzzing about what other villains and characters will make the cut. Can Noland and his crew keep up the quality for the third sequel? Here are some tips on how future Batman installments can live up to The Dark Knight.
Keep the Dynamic Duo of Nolan and Bale Together
In the
course of just two films, Christopher Nolan has crafted the richest,
most grounded comic book movies since the heyday of Richard Donner's Superman.
Meanwhile, Christian Bale gives us an intensely layered portrayal of
Bruce Wayne. Is it too much to hope for that the duo will stay with the
character indefinitely? Sean Connery lived with James Bond for decades.
The revolving door of directors and actors on the franchise have taken
us to some pretty brightly-colored places. (Ahem, Schumacher.) Nolan
and Bale are the De Niro and Scorsese of comic book films. Let's hope
they stay together.
Avoid Robin
Though he's been the subject of intense debate,
I'm erring on the side of no "Boy Blunder." While the Dick Grayson and
Tim Drake incarnations of Robin grew into their own in the comics, the
character makes little sense in the current franchise. Nolan and his
screenwriters have gone to great lengths to make every element of
Batman's onscreen universe seem plausible. A grown man running around
with a tights-wearing kid sidekick just doesn't fly in Nolan's world.
(And dredges up too many hack jokes and dated rumors.) Not to mention
that Batman is already getting crowded out of his own films, what with
Alfred, Gordon, Rachel Dawes, Lucius Fox, and multiple villains. Save
Robin for the inevitable Teen Titans movie, and keep Batman solo.
Tread Carefully Into the Rouges Gallery
Let's face it:
Batman has the coolest villains in comics. (Superman and Spidey should
be so lucky.) Unfortunately, he also has some of the campiest. A
psychotic clown-faced killer fits perfectly into Nolan's street-level
films, but a cat burglar who literally dresses up as a cat? Michelle
Pfeiffer created a brilliantly warped Catwoman for Batman Returns,
though the script did occasionally veer into purr-fectly awful puns.
(Sorry, couldn't resist.) The safest bet is to follow the lead of
Darwyn Cooke's noirish Catwoman comics and turn Selina into an ally and
informant to Batman, who also occasionally dips into cat burglary. And
how about casting an actress who is both sexy and sharp-witted?
(Zooey Deschanel, perhaps?) As for oddball crime boss the Penguin,
here's hoping the rumors of Philip Seymour Hoffman leading the Gotham
underworld actually pan out. If anyone can bring gravitas to one of the
more absurd Batman baddies, it's Hoffman. (But, please, Nolan, skip Mad
Hatter and Egghead entirely.)
Leap Into the Future
Should
Bale and Nolan decide to move on, Warner Bros. would be wise to restart
the franchise in the future. Far into the future, that is. Frank
Miller's seminal graphic novel The Dark Knight Returns,
featuring a retired Batman returning to the cape and cowl, is
practically begging to be adapted to film. (There's still time to play
Batman yet, Clint Eastwood!) Plus, it features quite possibly the
greatest Superman/Batman tussle in comic book history. Fans have been
waiting for a Dark Knight Returns adaptation for decades, and
with Miller currently on a cinematic high, the time is finally right.
In the meantime, this fan is looking forward to many Nolan/Bale
Bat-collaborations for years to come.
When not writing, Nick Nadel is in line at the comic book store alongside the other geeks, er, fans of speculative fiction. His most prized possession is a 1960s Batman comic wherein the Dynamic Duo are trapped inside a fortune cookie factory. He lives in Brooklyn and updates his aptly named website (nicknadel.com) with comedy writing and videos.




















I don't trust Kevin Smith after his glowing review of Revenge of the Sith, frankly. And as far as villains go, I'm hoping for a Clock King movie down the line, but I'm not holding my breath.
Clock King starred in one of my favorite episodes of "Batman: The Animated Series." (And later returned on Justice League Unlimited.) He's a great villain, but I think we'll have to wait awhile for that one. Frankly, I'd love to see The Riddler done right. Not as a Jim Carrey channeling The Mask jokester, but as a criminal genius with a mind to rival Bruce Wayne's.
Also, I think we can expect to see Jonathan Crane/Scarecrow again. And maybe a return from Ra's al Ghul? Introducing his daughter Talia as a love interest for Batman would be an improvement on the kinda bland, and not in the comics, Rachel Dawes. Even Vicki Vale turns up in the comics from time to time. (Though her character in the film was basically a stand-in for the awesomely named Silver St. Cloud.)
Looking further into the future, the "Batman Beyond" animated series was OK. Not sure who would play Bruce Wayne as an old man.
David Tennant (aka Doctor Who) has said he wants to play The Riddler.
I really hope Nolan has seen "Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire", because I totally agree he should play the part!
Dr.R.P-- Warners should make a live-action movie of the direct to DVD film Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker. Easily one of the best and darkest films produced by Warner Animation.
David Tennant would be an interesting choice for Riddler. I always thought Kevin Spacey would make a good Riddler after his role in Seven, but he's probably too old at this point.
Also, if Dark Knight Returns and/or Batman Beyond were ever adapted to film, it would make perfect sense to finally cast Mark Hamill as an older Joker. Imagine the fan frenzy that would ensue!
Brad Dourif had been considered as the Joker, way back when. I think he's a good fit for Nolan's Gotham.
David Tennet?! Oh please. One of the only critiques that I had of Ledger's Joker was the tongue flick as if he were secretly Barty Crouch Jr. using some polyjuice potion. Seriously, I would hate being reminded over and over again about that mental connection.