She's Hot, He's Not -- It Must Be Love

We have gotten so used to the male-female beauty imbalance in life and movies that we hardly remark about it anymore. It's so Beauty and the Beast.

The idea that a far-more-attractive woman is thrilled to be with a far-less-attractive man just seems intrinsically obvious to us. But why? Maybe it's one of women's superpowers: seeing the inner beauty in men, even when men don't have that same ability.

The latest case is The Five-Year Engagement, which hardly needs a plot summary -- duh, it's about a five-year-engagement between the characters played by Jason Segel and Emily Blunt, and whether they'll ever say, "I do." In the romcom, Segel's chef wears an apron with a really hot ripped body silkscreened on it. We see him often enough shirtless -- and pantless (why does Segel seem intent on taking off his pants? See Forgetting Sarah Marshall) -- to know he's hardly Ryan Reynolds. Meanwhile, he's partnered with Blunt, who would be the prettiest in a room full of pretty women.

Of course, Segel is not at all bad looking -- and he's tall. He's just not movie-star ripped. He's the kind of guy our moms would like us to bring home. And his character compensates for looks with charm bombs: He's cheeky, funny and sincere -- and he cooks.

There are plenty of movies that rely on the "hot woman, not-so-hot man" trope -- even ones directed by women, like Nancy Meyers' romcom The Holiday with Kate Winslet, Rufus Sewell, and Jack Black. Bridesmaids plays with the beauty balance, too. It begins by making the groom so plain as to be a nonentity. (Think hard: What did he look like?) The love object for Kristen Wiig's Annie -- the patient, long-suffering cop played by Chris O'Dowd -- is cute enough (a seven?), certainly not cuter than Annie. He does have the benefit of having his feet more firmly planted on the asphalt. And then there's Jon Hamm's Ted, the male ten. Ted is so much more conventionally handsome than Wiig that he exploits his power position in the beauty imbalance. He behaves as if he's doing Annie a favor by giving her the benefit of his company.

I confess, when I see Chris Hemsworth as Thor, he takes my breath away. (Cue audible sigh.) But if we were in the same bedroom, I think he would be too gorgeous for me. I'd be unpleasantly breathless and unable to communicate. For women, communication is every bit as hot as looks.

I was talking to the actress-director Julie Delpy (Before Sunrise) last week about her latest movie, 2 Days in New York, and that stunning actress told me something that resonated: "I'm not attracted to beauty or cuteness in men. For me, beautiful men, it lasts two weeks. It actually becomes annoying after a while. If they're good people then you love them; if they're bad people, it doesn't matter if they're beautiful."

Maybe the beauty imbalance -- she's hot, he's not so much -- works in part because women understand that surface beauty is a little like blue jeans: Throw them in the wash a few times and they start to shrink and fade. What really matters is the quality of the material.

No amount of external beauty is going to make the days you spend together go any faster. When you're sitting in the dark at the movies, what matters is that the person beside you laughs at the same jokes and holds your hand in the scary parts.

I'll go out on a limb here: Is it possible that the beauty imbalance is actually a pro-woman idea? Because it gives us the benefit of the doubt that even in a movie, a female character is driven by more profound desires than her male counterpart.



http://blogs.amctv.com/movie-blog/2012/04/shes-hot-hes-no.php AMC Blog type:title title:amc-blog amc_blog filmcritic type:filmcriti filmcriti:filmcritic beauty and the beast chris hemsworth emily blunt forgetting sarah marshall jack black jason segel julie delpy kate winslet kristen wiig rufus sewell the five-year engagement auto-tagged
  • Newest
    comment-stream childrenof:http://blogs.amctv.com/movie-blog/2012/04/shes-hot-hes-no.php reverseChronological
  • Oldest
    comment-stream childrenof:http://blogs.amctv.com/movie-blog/2012/04/shes-hot-hes-no.php chronological
  • Most Replied
    comment-stream childrenof:http://blogs.amctv.com/movie-blog/2012/04/shes-hot-hes-no.php repliesDescending
  • Most Liked
    comment-stream childrenof:http://blogs.amctv.com/movie-blog/2012/04/shes-hot-hes-no.php likesDescending
Comments:
childrenof:http://blogs.amctv.com/movie-blog/2012/04/shes-hot-hes-no.php
childrenof:http://blogs.amctv.com/movie-blog/2012/04/shes-hot-hes-no.php http://blogs.amctv.com/movie-blog/2012/04/shes-hot-hes-no.php AMC Blog type:title title:amc-blog amc_blog filmcritic type:filmcriti filmcriti:filmcritic beauty and the beast chris hemsworth emily blunt forgetting sarah marshall jack black jason segel julie delpy kate winslet kristen wiig rufus sewell the five-year engagement auto-tagged