Flashback Five - A Look Back at the Movies of Controversial Director Roman Polanski

polanski-560.jpg

flashback_five.JPG

As you may know, director Roman Polanski was arrested this week in Switzerland as a result of his fleeing the United States 30 years ago after he plead guilty to unlawful sex with a 13-year-old girl. Some members of Hollywood are up in arms. Their argument? Polanski is a brilliant filmmaker who doesn't deserve to be persecuted for a crime committed long ago, and that his victim has forgiven him. Great artistic achievement itself shouldn't excuse criminal behavior. But here's a question: What has Polanski directed that inspires such adulation? Following is an overview of his finest moments on the big screen in the English language.

1. The Pianist (2002)
The only movie to snag Polanski an Oscar for Best Director, The Pianist is an incredibly personal film as the story is grounded in the director's real-life escape from the Warsaw Ghetto in World War II. Arguably the most accomplished and heartfelt work of Polanski's career, this is justifiably his masterpiece.

2. Chinatown (1974)
This 1974 neo-noir is rightly considered a classic, but why? Is it Polanski's direction? The Oscar-winning screenplay by Robert Towne? The stellar performances by Jack Nicholson, Faye Dunaway and John Huston? It's hard to say, but Polanski's hand re-invigorated noir, and his facility for crafting strong characters is on full display.

3. Rosemary's Baby (1968)
Polanski tackles the supernatural genre with Mia Farrow playing the newest resident of a NYC apartment complex who discovers her neighbors are Satanists. (Worse yet, she's carrying the devil's child.) The movie's slow pace doesn't quite hold up to today's standards, but Polanski's sinister satire satire is enriched by a memorable performance by Farrow.

4. The Ninth Gate (1999)
Here Polanski returns to a genre he knows and loves, the supernatural thriller. Johnny Depp plays a used book dealer who stumbles on a plot to open the Gates of Hell. The movie bombed critically and financially, but there's still a lot to like, including Depp's signature quirkiness, and some deftly shot scenes of oft-ignored European locales.

5. Pirates (1986)
Years in development, this adventure-comedy was put on hold after Polanski ran from judgment in America. Eventually, the movie was made, starring Walter Matthau as cannibalistic Captain Red. Some consider Matthau's performance the prototype of Depp's Captain Jack Sparrow.

Honorable Mentions:

1. Death and the Maiden (1994) - Starring Sigourney Weaver as a torture victim, Polanksi's critically-lauded drama is a riveting work of suspense.

2. Bitter Moon (1992) - This drama finds the director in familiar waters, exploring the darker side of sexuality with stars Hugh Grant and Kristin Scott Thomas.

3. Frantic (1988) - Harrison Ford stars in this critically-lauded thriller as a surgeon forced into intrigue when his wife goes missing while vacationing in Paris.

4. Oliver Twist (2005) - Polanski plays safe with the umpteenth adaptation of the Charles Dickens story, recounted in exacting period detail.

5. Fearless Vampire Killers (1967) - An old-fashioned gothic oddity, this lavish, over-the-top comedy is a departure from Polanski's body of work.

rank-movies-btn.gif

Filed under: Flashback Five

Comments

default userpic

He deserves to be in jail; if he weren't a director, then he wouldn't be receiving such preferential treatment. Congrats to him for getting his victim's forgiveness, but don't forget the facts of the case. He DRUGGED and RAPED a 13 year old girl. A girl. It doesn't matter if he "didn't know" her age, he DRUGGED a female in order to force into having sex. And that's not sex, that's rape.

Oh yeah, and the he FLED the country for 30 years.

Not innocent. Jail time.

default userpic

He deserves to be in jail; if he weren't a famous director, he wouldn't be getting such preferential treatment. Sure, he got his victim's forgiveness, but people seem to have forgotten the facts of the case: he DRUGGED and RAPED a 13 year old GIRL. A 13 year old. I don't buy the excuse of "I didn't know how old she was." Doesn't matter; he DRUGGED someone in order to have sex with her. And that's not sex, that's RAPE.

And then he FLED the country for 30 years.

He deserves jail time for the original crimes and for the fleeing of justice.

Good ridence.

user-pic

@MadMommy: But his films are so good!

Kidding, I'm certainly not going to disagree with any of your points.

user-pic

I gotta go Chinatown as number one. Pianist is good, but pretty heavy-handed and mawkish. Chinatown is an outright masterpiece which, yes, is largely due to its screenplay. I'd also put Rosemary's Baby, a film which gets better every time I see it, ahead of Pianist.

And Polanski's greatest crime was appearing in Rush Hour 3. What, 30 years too soon?

user-pic

The only way I'd see Rush Hour 3 is if you plied me with drugs and alcohol.