Recognizing the Good, the Bad and the Ugly Dads of Horror

Blogger Stacie Ponder's horror columns appear every Wednesday.
Way back in the faraway, magical month of May, I wrote in praise of those horror movie moms who protect their children to the ends of the earth, to celebrate Mother's Day. Seeing as how Father's Day is upon us, it seems only fitting I explore the world of horror movie dads, no? Yes! However, I've discovered that horror movie dads are elusive creatures. They're generally underrepresented and when they are featured in a film, they don't tend to get the best shake. Most range from jerk to wicked jerk. But there's gotta be some good guys out there, right?
The Good
Why are there so few strong father figures in horror? Really, the genre could use a few more. Imagine how Norman Bates would have turned out if he'd had a dad to get him out of the house and away from his cuckoo nutso mom once in a while. Marion Crane, for one, might have had a happier life.
Norman certainly would have been served well by having a dad like Frank Carveth (Art Hindle). In David Cronenberg's twisted 1979 film, The Brood, Frank battles creepy snowsuit-clad, mutant-child dwarf-things to protect his daughter from her mother (Samantha Eggar), a woman so cuckoo-nutso, she literally gave birth to her own psychoses. Cronenberg reportedly wrote the film while he was embroiled in a tumultuous divorce and custody battle with his ex-wife. Hmm... tell us how you really feel about her, David!
Another dad going all out to fight for his daughter's life -- and his own -- is Frank (Brendan Gleeson) in 28 Days Later. What is it about dudes named Frank? Apparently they're the go-to guys if you're looking to get stuff done. Anyway, Frank manages to keep his daughter Hannah safe until, in one of the film's more heartbreaking sequences, he gets infected with the rage virus and a group of soldiers put him down.
The Bad
I gotta say, dads really shine as the bad guys in horror, albeit in varying degrees of badness. In 28 Weeks Later, the featured pop couldn't be more diametrically opposed to Frank from 28 Days if his name was Knarf. Okay, maybe that doesn't make sense, but come on: Don (Robert Carlyle) was one useless dad. To start with, he wimps out and leaves his wife to her doom at the hands and teeth of a whole slew of ragers. When he's finally infected himself, Don relentlessly pursues his children around London -- not because they've forgotten their lunches on their way to school, but because he wants to kill and perhaps eat them.
One horror movie father who's a bit less... murderific, but equally jerky, is Stan (Tom Atkins) in Creepshow. What kind of a dad calls comic books "crap" and takes them away? A dad who ends up on the receiving end of some voodoo doll pin action, that's what kind. Stan isn't the worst dad in Creepshow, however (and I'm not just saying that because I loves me some Tom Atkins) -- that honor undoubtedly goes to Nathan Grantham, featured in the appropriately-titled "Father's Day" segment. A righteous hardass in life and a zombified righteous hardass in death, Nathan infamously digs his way up from six feet under to make sure he gets his damn Father's Day cake. I know how he feels -- I'd probably come back from the dead for a slice of red velvet cake.
Before he ended up stranded on some weirdo island on Lost, Terry O'Quinn was a hardworking family man. OK, he was a hardworking family man with a quick temper and a nasty tendency to kill when things didn't go his way. Yes, folks, Terry O'Quinn was the stepfather from hell in The Stepfather and its sequel, Stepfather 2. All he wanted was a perfect family -- was that too much to ask? The Stepfather movies are perfect Sunday afternoon schlock, carried along nicely by O'Quinn's performance. I've yet to see the third film in the series with Robert Wightman doing what I assume is his best to fill O'Quinn's shoes; both actors play the same character, Keith Grant, a man who seems to have a really tough time finding that special lady and kids to settle down with long-term.
While Wendy Torrance (Shelley Duvall) made my awesome horror moms list, her husband Jack (Jack Nicholson) is another matter entirely. You could argue that the big villain in Stanley Kubrick's The Shining is actually the haunted Overlook Hotel, but Jack is the cipher through which the Overlook gets its dirty deeds done... and boy oh boy, does Jack do some bad deeds. He sucker-axes Scatman Crothers in the back (guess his shinin' didn't see that one coming!), he terrorizes his wife and son with baseball bats, axes and weird faces, and as if these evil acts weren't enough, Jack blatantly wastes a whole lot of paper. While purportedly "working on his book," the guy fills up ream after ream with useless "All work and no play" nonsense. How many trees had to die so you could procrastinate, Jack? Hmm? How many?
The Ugly
I
know it's not fair to judge a man (or his family) by the way he looks,
but sometimes you really just have to. Case in point: Pa (Ken
Kirzinger) in Wrong Turn 2.
The dude is a mess -- an inbred, deformed weirdo mess. And a mess who also
kills and cannibalizes so, therefore, I have no qualms about calling
him plain old ugly. There are several lessons to be learned from the
story of Ugly Pa: Don't kill, don't cannibalize, and for the love of
Pete, don't inbreed.
And if that's not a topic of discussion fit for Father's Day dinner, then I don't know what is!
A fan of horror movies and scary stuff, Stacie Ponder started her blog Final Girl so she'd have a platform from which she could tell everyone that, say, Friday the 13th, Part 2 rules. She leads a glamorous life, walking on the razor's edge of danger and intrigue.




















I totally forgot that it was Terry O'Quinn in "Stepfather." If you ask me all Keith was guilty of really was caring too much. OF course I haven't seen the movie in years so maybe I'm remembering wrong...
Also what about Roy Scheider's Martin Brody from "Jaws" for a good father? I mean the man got past his fear of water so that he could hunt down a man eating Squalus carcharias that was potentially threatening his family (and the families of others). Thats a good dad, right?
I have to say, Don wasn't very smart, was he? Especially when he enters a QUARANTINED ROOM to see his wife.
Moron...
Great call on Brody, Pierce! I totally spaced on that one.
The goodest dad would have to be Keith David(David Keith?) in Firestarter! The crap he went through to protect lil' Drew.
Would Firestarter even be considered horror?
What about Thomas Jane in "The Mist"?
---- SPOILER ALERT-----
I mean c'mon, a dad that puts a bullet in his kids brain case to keep him from being eaten by nasty interdimensional monsters.....
Nancy's Dad in Nightmare on Elm Street! Given that he honestly thinks his daughter is going a little crazy, it's understandable that he doesn't take her too seriously; and when it counts, he shows up to beat the door down and charge to the rescue.
What about the Dad in the movie House?